Mastering Management: Dealing with stubborn employees

woman with paper with cross sign
Photo by Anete Lusina on


Dealing with stubborn employees can be challenging for managers. These problematic behaviors not only hinder productivity but also create unnecessary tension in the workplace.

In this blog post, we’ll explore various techniques and strategies to help you effectively manage these challenging personalities and promote a harmonious working environment.

Understanding Difficult Employee Behaviors

human resources department

Complex employee behaviors manifest in various ways, including stubbornness, defensiveness, and defiance, often rooted in underlying personal or workplace issues that require a more profound understanding to address effectively.

Characteristics Of Stubborn, Defensive, Or Defiant Employees

Understanding the characteristics of stubborn, defensive, or defiant employees is essential in developing effective strategies to manage these behaviors. These traits can manifest in various ways, including:

1. Resistance to change: Stubborn employees may need help adapting to new processes or policies and often push back against any alterations in their work routines.

2. Frequent arguments: Defiant employees are prone to confront managers and coworkers about tasks, decisions, or workplace issues.

3. Inability to accept criticism: Defensive employees often take any constructive feedback personally and may respond with hostility or denial.

4. Blaming others: These employees may refuse to take responsibility for their actions and instead place blame on colleagues or supervisors.

5. Negative attitude: Stubborn, defensive, or defiant employees often display a pessimistic outlook on work matters and resist positive organizational changes.

6. Passive-aggressive behavior: Rather than voicing concerns openly, these individuals may resort to indirect communication methods such as gossiping, complaining behind others’ backs, or sabotaging projects.

7. Poor collaboration skills: These employees need help to work effectively as part of a team and may even undermine group efforts if they disagree with the overall direction.

8. Lack of flexibility: Stubborn employees insist on following their preferred approach and refuse improvement suggestions.

9. Disregard for authority: Defiant individuals often challenge managerial decisions or ignore directives from supervisors.

Recognizing these characteristics is the first step towards addressing problematic employee behaviors and creating a more harmonious work environment for all team members.

Root Causes Of Difficult Behavior

Problematic employee behavior can stem from various underlying factors. These root causes may include personal issues, lack of motivation or engagement, poor work-life balance, low job satisfaction, or feeling undervalued.

For instance, a stubborn employee who is hesitant to change could be experiencing anxiety about having to learn new skills or feeling overwhelmed by their workload. A defensive employee may feel insecure about their abilities and interpret feedback as criticism instead of constructive input for improvement.

Signs Of Difficult Employee Behavior

Complex employee behavior can manifest in various ways, and it’s essential to identify the signs of such behavior to address them effectively. Here are some common signs of complex employee behavior:

1. Constantly challenging or questioning authority

2. Consistently missing deadlines or failing to meet performance expectations

3. Refusing to follow instructions or complete assigned tasks

4. Frequently interrupting or talking over others during meetings

5. Displaying a negative attitude towards colleagues or managers

6. Being defensive and resistant to feedback or constructive criticism

7. Blaming others for mistakes or failures instead of taking responsibility 

8. Engaging in argumentative behavior and being combative with coworkers 

9. Displaying aggressive behavior like yelling, slamming doors, or throwing things 

10. Showing signs of disrespect towards colleagues and managers 

To maintain a productive workplace, enhance team dynamics, and foster good employee connections is essential to address these behaviors.

Effective Strategies For Managing Difficult Employees

human resources department

To effectively manage difficult employees, practice active listening to understand their perspective, communicate clearly and assertively to establish boundaries and expectations, provide constructive feedback to help them improve, offer training and support to develop necessary skills, and set clear consequences for not meeting expectations.

Practice Active Listening

Active listening is essential for any manager hoping to manage a problematic employee successfully. It involves giving full attention to the person speaking, acknowledging their feelings and concerns, and responding non-judgmentally.

This approach builds trust between you and the employee while fostering open communication necessary for resolving disagreements or conflicts quickly. For instance, instead of interrupting them or dismissing their concerns outrightly, you could repeat what they’ve said back to them in your words; this demonstrates that you have understood their message correctly while showing empathy towards their situation.

Communicate Clearly And Assertively

Effective communication is critical in managing difficult employees. When dealing with stubborn, defensive, or defiant employees, it’s essential to communicate clearly and assertively.

It means being direct and specific when addressing their behavior and expectations for improvement.

For example, instead of saying, “You need to stop acting out,” a more practical approach would be something like, “I noticed you were resistant during our last meeting. Can you share what’s causing your frustration?” By asking open-ended questions and creating a safe space for dialogue, managers can help diffuse tension while still addressing problematic behavior head-on.

Provide Constructive Feedback

Providing constructive feedback is one of the most effective strategies for managing difficult employees. It involves giving specific, actionable feedback that focuses on behavior rather than personality.

For instance, instead of saying, “You have a bad attitude which affects team morale,” say, “When you are not responsive to emails from your team members, it creates delays in project completion.” Ensure your feedback is timely and delivered with respect and empathy.

Ask the employee if they have any other questions or concerns before concluding each feedback session.

Offer Training And Support

Providing your stubborn, defensive, or defiant employees with the necessary training and support is essential. It will help them acquire new skills and knowledge while developing confidence in their abilities.

You can offer different types of training such as online courses, workshops, or seminars to improve their job-related tasks. In addition, providing tailored coaching and mentoring sessions that address specific areas where the employee could improve is also an essential step toward improving the employee’s performance.

Set Clear Expectations And Consequences

One effective strategy for managing difficult employees is to set clear expectations and consequences. Being specific and transparent about the employee’s expectations regarding job responsibilities, behavior, and performance metrics is essential.

In addition to setting clear expectations, it’s also essential to establish consequences for failing to meet those expectations. Managers may promote team responsibility by defining clear objectives and punishments.

Managers may promote responsibility and create a more favorable work atmosphere by defining clear expectations and repercussions.

Documenting And Addressing The Behavior

human resources department

Documenting the behavior is crucial in addressing difficult employees, as it provides a clear understanding of the actions and enables you to develop an effective improvement plan.

Documenting The Behavior

Documenting the behavior of difficult employees is essential in managing their performance. Here are some tips on how to document their behavior effectively:

1. Be specific: When documenting, be as specific about your observed behavior. Include dates, times, and examples.

2. Use objective language: Use accurate language when describing the behavior. Avoid using subjective terms that may be open to interpretation.

3. Keep it professional: Avoid making personal attacks or accusations when documenting an employee’s behavior. Stick to the facts and keep your tone professional.

4. Get input from others: Get information from colleagues or managers who have witnessed the same behavior to provide additional perspective and support for your documentation.

5. Provide feedback: Once you have documented the employee’s behavior, provide them with feedback on what you observed and how it needs to change moving forward.

6. Follow up: Ensure that you follow up with the employee regularly to monitor their progress and document any changes in their behavior.

Documenting problematic employee behaviors is crucial for managing their performance effectively while protecting yourself and your organization from potential legal disputes in the future.

Meeting With The Employee

Once you’ve documented the behavior and gathered all relevant information, it’s time to discuss their behavior with the problematic employee. This meeting is an opportunity to share your concerns about their behavior, provide feedback on how they can improve, and develop a plan for moving forward.

During the meeting, start by acknowledging the employee’s strengths and contributions to the team before addressing any negative behavior. Then, clearly explain what specific behaviors you’ve observed causing issues and why it’s essential for them to change.

Be sure to allow employees time to express their perspectives and ask questions. Develop a plan of action with the employee that includes specific goals and timelines for improvement.

Lastly, plan follow-up meetings to keep track of the work done toward those goals and provide continued assistance whenever required.

Addressing The Behavior And Providing Feedback

When dealing with difficult employees, addressing their behavior directly and providing constructive feedback is essential. This process should involve documenting the behavior, meeting with the employee, and discussing specific examples of inappropriate actions or attitudes.

Offering concrete suggestions for improvement can help manage difficult employees. For example, a manager might suggest time-management or goal-setting techniques if an employee repeatedly misses deadlines.

On the other hand, consistently positive behaviors should be recognized and rewarded when possible to encourage continued success.

Establishing A Plan For Improvement

Once you’ve documented the problematic behavior and provided feedback to the employee, it’s essential to establish an improvement plan. This plan should be specific, measurable, and achievable within a reasonable timeframe.

Start by identifying the root causes of their complex behavior and work together on addressing them effectively. Set clear goals for improvement with deadlines for completion.

Regularly check in with your employees to track progress, offer support, and provide constructive feedback.

Tips For New Managers In Dealing With Difficult Employees

Dealing with stubborn, defensive, or defiant employees

If you’re a new manager struggling with difficult employees, follow these tips:

  • Establish clear expectations and boundaries.
  • Develop a plan for addressing challenging behaviors.
  • Seek support and guidance from experienced managers.
  • Prioritize self-care and boundary setting.

You can effectively manage even the most stubborn or defiant employees with time and patience.

Establishing Clear Expectations And Boundaries

As a manager, setting clear expectations and boundaries while managing difficult employees is vital. It involves communicating your expectations for behavior, performance, and job responsibilities directly and assertively.

For example, if you have an employee who constantly pushes back on instructions given, you should make sure they understand their job duties by outlining them clearly during training sessions.

Setting attainable key performance metrics manages employee expectations. Addressing the troublesome behavior will help you and your team define success.

Developing A Plan For Addressing Difficult Behaviors

Developing a plan for addressing a problematic employee is crucial to effectively managing their behavior. Here are some steps to consider:

1. Identify the behaviors causing issues and how they impact the team.

2. Consult with HR or other managers to determine appropriate actions and consequences.

3. Schedule a meeting with the difficult employee to discuss the problematic behavior and its impact.

4. Work collaboratively with the employee to establish a clear action plan for improvement.

5. Ensure that goals and expectations are clearly defined, measurable, and achievable.

6. Provide necessary support or training resources to help the employee succeed.

7. Continually monitor progress towards agreed-upon goals and provide regular feedback.

8. Celebrate successes along the way while also holding employees accountable for ongoing improvement.

By developing an individualized plan for addressing challenging behavior, managers can show their commitment to supporting employees while promoting accountability and respectful workplace culture.

Seeking Support And Guidance From Experienced Managers

As a new manager, it’s essential to recognize that difficult employees can be challenging to manage. Seeking support and guidance from experienced managers is an effective way to develop the skills and confidence needed to handle these situations effectively.

Moreover, you can also attend workshops or seminars on employee management, conflict resolution, communication skills development, leadership styles, motivational strategies, emotional intelligence, and professional development programs, amongst others.

These resources allow you to learn from professionals with years of experience managing people in different industries and scenarios.

Prioritizing Self-Care And Boundary Setting

Managing difficult employees can be a challenging task for any manager or leader. It’s important to remember that their behavior is not a reflection of your leadership skills but rather an opportunity to address the problem and find practical solutions.

One crucial aspect of successfully managing difficult employees is prioritizing self-care and boundary-setting. As a manager, it’s common to invest so much time and energy into addressing the employee’s behavior that you neglect your well-being.

To prioritize self-care, you need to set clear boundaries for yourself regarding what you are willing and able to do as a manager. For example, suppose an employee continually violates company rules despite multiple warnings. In that case, it may be more beneficial in the long run to terminate their employment rather than exhaust all possible disciplinary measures.

Establishing these boundaries will allow you to control situations without sacrificing your mental health or jeopardizing your job performance.

Conclusion And Importance Of Addressing Difficult Employees.

In conclusion, managing difficult employees requires practical communication skills, assertiveness, and precise documentation of behaviors. Addressing the root causes of their behavior and providing constructive feedback while setting clear expectations for improvement is essential.

Ignoring problematic behavior can lead to a toxic workplace culture that affects productivity, employee engagement, and retention rates. As a manager or leader, it is crucial to prioritize self-care and seek support from experienced colleagues when handling challenging employees.

Implementing strategies such as strength-based management, coaching, and mentoring programs alongside conflict resolution techniques in HR policies and procedures can make a significant difference in addressing these difficulties head-on.

For more on this topic, see Understanding Different Types Of Leaders.